The Facebook Eye

Emile Zola famously stated back in 1901, “In my view, you cannot claim to have really seen something until you have photographed it.” Today, some make a similar joke: “It did not happen unless it is posted on Facebook.”

For those who use Facebook, whose friends are on the site and logging in many times a day, we have come to experience the world differently. We are increasingly aware of how our lives will look as a Facebook photo, status update or check-in. As I type this in a coffee shop, I can “check-in” on Foursquare, I can “tweet” a funny one-liner overheard from the table next to me and I can take an ‘interesting’ photo of the perfectly-formed foam on top of my cappuccino. It is easy; I can do all of this and more from my phone in a matter of minutes. And, most importantly, there will be an audience for all of this. Hundreds of the people I am closest with will view all of this and some will reply with comments and “likes.”

Simply, I have been trained to see the world in terms of what I can post to the Internet. I’ve learned to live and present a life that is “likeable.”

Many have rightly criticized Facebook over how the site turns the unquantifiable beauty of human experience into something that fits into a database , or how Facebook misuses that database to earn fantastic profits. These are valid critiques; however, my concern is that the ultimate power of social media is how it burrows into us, our minds, our consciousness, changing how we consciously experience the world even when logged off.

The photographer knows well that after taking many pictures one develops “the camera eye”: vision becomes like the viewfinder, always perceiving the world through the logic of the camera mechanism via framing, lighting, depth of field, focus, movement and so on. Even without the camera in hand the world becomes transformed into the status of the potential-photograph.

Today, we are in danger of developing a “Facebook Eye”: our brains always looking for moments where the ephemeral blur of lived experience might best be translated into a Facebook post; one that will draw the most comments and “likes.”

Facebook fixates the present as always a future past. By this I mean that social media users have become always aware of the present as something we can post online that will be consumed by others. Are we becoming so concerned about posting our lives on Facebook that we forget to live our lives in the here-and-now? Think of a time when you took a trip holding a camera in your hand and then think of when you did the same without the camera. The experience is slightly different. We have a different attachment to our present when we are not concerned with documenting.

Today, social media means we are always traveling with the camera in our hands (metaphorically and often literally); we always can document. When going to see live music I notice more and more people distracted from the performance in order to take photos and videos to post to Facebook and YouTube. When the breakfast I made the other week looked especially delicious, I posted a photo of it before even taking a bite. The Facebook Eye in action.

Susan Sontag once wrote that “everything exists to end in a photograph” and today we might say that more and more of what we do exists to end up on Facebook.

The tail of Facebook documentation has come to wag the dog of lived experience.

This essay was originally published in Italian for the newspaper Corriere della Sera. You can find it here 

16 Replies to “The Facebook Eye”

  1. Beautiful, thought-provoking writing. I am the same way with blogging as you mention about facebook and twitter. When out, I am always thinking, “could I blog this?” and often go do things just for that purpose. Social media can define our lives if we aren’t careful to “to live our lives in the here-and-now.” Great post!


  2. This is why I avoid Facebook even though I’m tempted to get one because I moved, I know I will become obsessed with it. I don’t have one, and it seems like everywhere I go on the internet it’s encouraging me to log in my with my Facebook account… which I don’t have. I would think it’d be very easy to be caught up in posting that you forget to live in the moment.


  3. Very perceptive and thought provoking.So as we morph into “social media” organisms, do we start losing out something more intrinsic and genuine in our interactions? Do we instinctively start wearing “masks” during every waking moment?

    Loved the post!



  4. Reblogged this on byroisinhealy and commented:
    This is a scarily thought-provoking post about the all-consuming nature of Facebook. Reading this, I remember how on holiday in Barcelona with my boyfriend I barely saw his face because he always had a camera in front of it, and of the amount of times on nights out we all spend gathered around phones making sure the WiFi works so we can check in. I think the world is definitely in need of a social media detox.


  5. When I was gone for a month to France back in June, I was crushed that my laptop died the night before I left. After being there for a month and getting used to not posting on FB more than maybe once or twice a week, I was amazed by how much more I experienced and saw because I wasn’t always thinking of having to post on FB. Now that I’m back in the States, I’m hoping to not be too hooked to FB. You definitely make a good point. Our lives are often easily centered around getting acceptance from “likes” on FB rather than actually living and experiencing life.


  6. Tom, what a wonderful post. Time ago, you wrote a similar post in which you included the same phrase: “Are we becoming so concerned about posting our lives on Facebook that we forget to live our lives in the here-and-now?” Do you have the link of that post? I looked for it in your blog but I did not find it. I would be glad if you facilitate me the link, for I want to reread it. Blessings.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s